Provest Group has released an insights paper urging South African mining leaders to pay closer attention to the hazards that never make it into safety reports because employees fear the consequences of speaking up.
Psychological Safety as South African Mining’s Silent Critical Control, authored by the Group’s Head SHEQ Manager, Karel Matthews, argues that even comprehensive engineering controls and reporting procedures can miss key warning signs when workers do not feel safe to speak up. A deteriorating ground condition or malfunctioning safety device can remain unaddressed even when someone has noticed the warning signs.
A peer-reviewed study of 927 South African mine workers found that 31% were experiencing moderate to severe psychological distress. A separate 2024 study in Western Australia found that around one in three near misses and one in four notifiable incidents went unreported in the preceding year. On any mine, that level of underreporting would leave management with serious gaps in its understanding of what is happening on site.
“Mining companies make substantial investments in keeping people safe, but leaders also need to understand what those systems are not telling them,” says Funani Mojono, CEO of Provest. “If a worker believes raising a concern could threaten their reputation or livelihood, vital information may never reach the people responsible for acting on it. Creating the conditions for people to speak openly is a leadership responsibility and an important part of managing an operation well.”
Matthews says how supervisors handle reported hazards or mistakes can influence whether workers are willing to raise concerns in the future. This is particularly important during pre-shift briefings, where employees need to feel comfortable questioning instructions or pointing out potential risks.
“A worker can notice a problem and still decide to say nothing if they expect to be blamed or dismissed. How a supervisor responds tells everyone else on that shift how their own concerns are likely to be received. We need workers to know their observations will be taken seriously, and we need to follow through so that reporting leads to action,” says Matthews.
Senior leaders can leave a site visit believing everything is under control, even when workers have concerns they have kept to themselves. The paper explores why this happens and identifies four leadership behaviours that require no new safety management system. Matthews expands on this framework in the full paper.
“Every mine knows its incident rate. Far fewer know how many hazards workers have seen and chosen not to report,” concludes Matthews.
The full insights paper is available at Psychological Safety as South African Mining’s Silent Critical Control
